There had been reports this past week of a Chat as well as an immature Red Shouldered Hawk continuing on the east side of Mill Pond in Bellmore. It seemed rather cooperative for most birders so I tried my luck in the early morning to try to find it. Other birders had reported it in the area of the east trail/ side of the lake near a house being renovated and had a blue tarp on it. I found the house and did a thorough search of the area - no luck. I think I was there for about 30 minutes when I decided to give up and leave. Not to be totally defeated I walked slowly back and the Chat popped up but a while south of the area where everyone else was reporting it. I got some good views of it as it was looking for food heading back north to where it had reported the day before. I wanted to get totally unobstructed photos of it since I had seen other birders photos of it out in the open, but it was doing it's thing traveling through the shrubs so I didn't want to bother it too much and let it be.
I can't help but think other birders who tried and didn't find the chat like I did were relying too much on the observations of other birders. I have seen several times where birders will just stick to one particular location where a bird was last seen - not making any other attempt to look around it and take some initiative. I was sort of guilty of doing that with the chat but decided not to give up and it paid off eventually.
(I ran out of time for my morning outing so I did not attempt to find the Red Shouldered Hawk)